By Joel Wong, Chair of the Judges, Asian American Stories Video Contest, Silicon Valley Community Media (SVCM)
A striking disconnect has existed between mainstream Western media portrayals of China and the firsthand accounts of visitors since 2023. While Western outlets often frame China as a dystopian, authoritarian state facing economic decay and “Orwellian” surveillance, tourists and expats describe a safe, hyper-modern society defined by seamless technology and a vibrant urban life.
The Great Divide
Media Narratives: Western coverage focuses on systemic issues—youth unemployment, property crises, and human rights—often framing China as a geopolitical rival. This “conflict-driven” journalism can overlook rapid progress, such as poverty eradication and environmental improvements.
Visitor Experiences: Since the 2024 surge in inbound tourism and relaxed visa policies, social media has been flooded with praise for China’s high-speed rail, ubiquitous EVs, and public safety. Visitors often feel their “boots-on-the-ground” reality contradicts the “oppressive” atmosphere described back home.
Why the Discrepancy?
The gap stems from several factors:
Selection Bias: Tourists visit polished hubs like Shenzhen or Shanghai, rarely encountering rural disparities or sensitive political restrictions.
Geopolitical Filters: Rising tensions incentivize Western media to highlight threats, while the Chinese state promotes positive influencer content.
Rate of Change: China’s digital and green transitions have outpaced outdated international stereotypes.
Ultimately, both perspectives offer fragments of a complex reality. While the media identifies systemic risks, visitors humanize the nation’s modernization. As travel continues to scale in 2026, these firsthand accounts serve as a crucial, if incomplete, counter-narrative to traditional media framing.
Visit joelwong.net for all my blogs.
